or Batgirl in that film Joss Whedon dropped out of, Conan O’Brien has his own picks in mind.

Schaal had to bring her baby to audition because she couldn’t find a babysitter and mamma’s gotta work. Meanwhile, Swank brought one of the two Oscars she won for Million Dollar Baby and Boys Don’t Cry as proof of her excellence.

“Hilary Swank read for this? She bring her Oscar in with her?” Foster asked. Swank didn’t bring in a knight with her, though, so Foster had the edge in that respect.

Between Bamford hanging upside down like a bat, Byer acting as if Batman and Robin were storming her “Batcave,” Notaro’s deadpan line read, and the unexpected arrivals of Thomas Middleditch and Nick Offerman, something tells us we haven’t found Hollywood’s Batgirl just yet.