Scream Queens, Ryan Murphy’s newest mix of fun and gore, is off to a killer start. It’s good news for everyone who likes to have some bloody good time in front of their TV, but sad news for Ariana Grande, whose Chanel #2 (yes, that’s her name) has fallen victim to Kappa Kappa Tau’s very own psychopath known as Red Devil. And while the sorority sisters are trying to piece together the mystery behind all the hilarious mayhem, we’re taking a stab at predicting who’s going to join the ever-expanding cast of the horror comedy series. Here are eight cameo’s we’d kill to see in Scream Queens.

Sarah Michelle Gellar

Apart from saving the world (a lot) as the most iconic television blonde named Buffy Summers, Sarah Michelle Gellar also earned a title of the ‘90s ultimate scream queen after her memorable stints in Scream 2 and I Know What You Did Last Summer. She also proved she’s got a knack for all things bitchy (Cruel Intentions) and funny (the short-lived The Crazy Ones series), which pretty much makes her a perfect applicant for a Scream Queens cameo.

Lana Del Rey

As he’s already recruited the goddess of all things weird Lady Gaga for the current American Horror Story season, it would make perfect sense for Ryan Murphy to invite her nemesis Lana Del Rey to join the blooming Scream Queens cast. Death and Americana have always been parts of her aesthetics, so why not temper the lampooning vibe of the show with a healthy dose of that summertime, summertime sadness?

Rebecca Black

Murphy’s already put The Real Housewives of Atlanta’s NeNe Leakes into his television army, so why not tear off from reality TV for a bit and dive into the world of the YouTube wonders? The “Friday” crooner already proved she’s up for a fun cameo when she guest starred in Katy Perry’s “Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F)” video alongside Glee’s Kevin McHale and Darren Criss. Perhaps it was all that social media bullying that made Black put on the Red Devil costume and turn a fun Friday night into Friday the 13^th? Just an idea!

Jane Lynch

Scream Queens already have a Sue Sylverster-esque character in the face of Jamie Lee Curtis’ Dean Munch, so wouldn’t it be fun to bring in the most vicious Glee alumni as a peaceful character? Don’t tell us you didn’t dream about seeing coach Sue’s gruesome murder at least ones of twice during the 6-year-run of Glee!

Oprah Winfrey

Scream Queens’ plot revolves around a radical change in the Kappa life, which sees the notoriously picky sorority opening its glamorous doors to any girl (and possibly a gay boy, too) who’d like to pledge. So a famous warrior for equality and TV godmother would make a perfect addition to the show. Who knows, maybe Oprah’s the one who lets Emma Roberts’ Chanel borrow the private jet she liked to brag about.

Sharon Stone

Our basic instinct tells us that ‘90s sexiest serial killer would be right at home at the blood-dripping walls of Kappa Kappa Tau. As if the resident queen bees of the killer sorority didn’t study the art of strutting in high heels and possibly the technic of throat slashing from Stone’s Catherine Tramell anyway.

Rose McGowan

Given the fact that the opening scene of Scream Queens’ premiere was an obvious nod to the cult teen comedy Jawbreaker, it would be pretty reasonable for Ryan Murphy to give its lead a call. We’re sure Rose would say yes: last year she guest starred in Charli XCX’s high school-themed video “Break The Rules,” so this ‘90s bad girl is obviously up for a fun day at the set.

Lorde

She did say we can call her queen bee, right? Plus New Zealand’s coolest kid was already name-checked in Scream Queens. And if American Horror Story taught us anything, it’s that if there’s a Stevie Nicks fan in the house, there’s most likely a cameo in the cards. Lorde may also bring her pal Taylor Swift to fill in the blank space left after Kappa House’s biggest TS fan was (spoiler!) mowed off the show.